The Perfect Choice Fallacy and Beating Worry: A Path to Clarity
We’ve all been there—standing in front of a menu at a restaurant, scrolling through endless options online, or even hesitating over which movie to watch. In many cases, the search for the “perfect” choice leads us into a spiral of indecision, worry, and ultimately, paralysis. What drives this paralyzing fear of choosing wrong? Why do some people spend hours obsessing over relatively small decisions, like buying a jacket or picking a paint color?
It’s rooted in a common psychological trap known as The Perfect Choice Fallacy—the mistaken belief that there is a "perfect" choice that will remove all uncertainty and risk. This is tied to how we handle worry, indecisiveness, and anxiety, particularly for those suffering from Generalised Anxiety Disorder (GAD). Let’s break it down and look at how to beat these unhelpful thinking habits, regain control, and make decisions with more confidence and less stress.
The Nature of Worry: A Process, Not a Problem
Worry isn’t always a response to a specific threat. For people with GAD, worry becomes a process that’s less about the specific content and more about uncertainty itself. The content of worries often changes day to day, but what remains constant is an intolerance of uncertainty.
Take a common theme, like the fear of judgment: a person might worry excessively about an upcoming presentation one day and then about what their friends think of them the next. It’s not the particular topic that drives the worry—it’s the discomfort with not knowing how things will turn out.
The real trap here is that focusing on the content of worries is like chasing a moving target. You might address today’s worry, but tomorrow, there’s a new one. The key lies in addressing the process—the underlying intolerance of uncertainty that drives the need to worry in the first place. And the only way to overcome this is to build tolerance for uncertainty, not by eliminating it.
The 6 Types of Uncontrollable Worry and How to Overcome Them
Let’s look at some common forms of worry that keep us stuck in this cycle, and how to break free:
1. Fear of Judgment
Worrying about what others think can lead to avoidance and hesitation. Behavioural experiment: Start by making a choice without seeking reassurance. Wear the outfit, give the presentation, and notice what happens. Often, the feared judgment doesn’t materialise or is far less intense than expected.
2. Fear of Making Mistakes
The belief that every decision must be flawless leads to perfectionism and paralysis. Counter this by making small, deliberate choices where you allow for mistakes, like picking a paint color or choosing a restaurant without triple-checking reviews.
3. Fear of Wasting Time
Spending hours debating the “best” option feels productive but is often draining. Limit decision-making time. Set a timer for 15 minutes to make a decision, and stick to it. Remember, there’s no "perfect" answer.
4. Need for Control
We often seek to control everything to avoid uncertainty. Try going grocery shopping without a list and allow yourself to embrace spontaneity.
5. Fear of Being Imperfect
This fear often leads to endless refinement and second-guessing. Embrace imperfections by making a choice with just three criteria (e.g., “I want a jacket under £40, in black or tan”). Once you’ve made the choice, throw away the receipt and commit to it.
6. Fear of Regret
We worry that we’ll regret our decisions, leading to procrastination or indecision. A great tool is a worry outcome journal—write down your worry, the decision you made, and the eventual outcome. More often than not, the regret you fear never actually materialises, and documenting this can help challenge that assumption.
Unhelpful Behaviours That Fuel Indecisiveness
It’s not just the worry itself that keeps us stuck—it’s how we respond to the worry that perpetuates the cycle. Some common behaviors that fuel indecisiveness include:
Procrastination: Delaying decisions to avoid the discomfort of choosing wrong.
Information seeking: Trying to reduce uncertainty by gathering excessive data, but never feeling satisfied.
Reassurance seeking: Asking others for their opinions to ease the anxiety of decision-making, which undermines your own confidence.
Avoidance: Not making a decision feels safer than making the wrong one.
Delegating decisions: Passing the responsibility onto others to avoid potential mistakes.
Partial commitment: Trying to reduce committment and therefore responsibility.
Minimising: For example: "this place might not be good I haven’t really been here or thought about it much" - this makes you less responsible, but it also means you can never own your victories!
Impulsive decision making: A pick out of a hat attitude where the decision gets made, but no responsibility could be taken.
The decision dance: Switching between information, reassurance seeking and procrastination – if I dance around it long enough the perfect choice will reveal itself.
These behaviours, while aimed at reducing uncertainty, ironically create more of it. The more you delay or rely on external input, the more overwhelmed you become, the more information you input, the more effort you put in, the higher the anxiety.
Maximisers vs. Satisficers: Two Approaches to Decision-Making
To understand decision-making better, consider two common styles:
- Maximisers: These individuals seek the best possible outcome, evaluating every single option before deciding. While this seems like a thorough approach, maximisers often end up less satisfied because they fear they’ve missed something better.
- Satisficers: These individuals look for “good enough” options that meet their criteria. They make decisions faster and feel more content with their choices because they accept that perfection is unattainable.
Take buying a jacket as an example. A maximiser would visit every store, compare every jacket, and agonize over details like stitching. A satisficer, on the other hand, would choose a jacket that fits basic criteria (black, under £40) and walk away satisfied. Which one are you in different areas of your life?
How to Break the Cycle of Indecisiveness and Worry
To break out of the worry cycle, it’s essential to experiment with behavior that challenges your intolerance of uncertainty. Here are a few strategies:
1. Practice making choices under time limits: Force yourself to make decisions within a set time frame with limited criteria.
2. Use a worry outcome journal: This is a powerful tool to challenge the belief that something catastrophic will happen if you make the wrong choice. Track your decisions and outcomes daily to realise that most of your fears don’t come true, or when they do, they’re manageable.
3. Drop the need for reassurance: Make a decision without asking others for validation. This builds self-trust and confidence. Dropping this and other safety behaviours will make you more anxious in the first instance as you are tolerating that uncertainty, but will help in the long run.
4. Set criteria and commit: For every decision, choose 1-3 key criteria, make the decision, and own it. The more you practice, the more your tolerance for uncertainty will grow.
5. Experiment with uncertainty: Engage in small behavioral experiments like going out without a plan, choosing a random paint color, or shopping without a list. Sit with the discomfort, and note how you handle the outcome.
Embrace the “Good Enough” Mindset
Indecisiveness and chronic worry are often driven by the same thing: an intolerance for uncertainty. By focusing on reducing this discomfort—rather than trying to eliminate uncertainty entirely—you’ll free yourself from the loop of second-guessing and procrastination.
The goal is not to stop worrying altogether, but to develop a tolerance for uncertainty, make decisions more confidently, and be kinder to yourself when things don’t go perfectly. Start small, experiment, and slowly you’ll see that most of your worries never materialise, and the ones that do are far less catastrophic than you feared.
Comments